Sunday, February 28, 2016

No, Donald Trump is not "Destroying" the Republican Party

...
The Party will be fine. Different, but fine...
The Republican Party has been at loggerheads with itself for decades. As a political organization, it existed to serve the needs of business and the wealthy. Ideologically it was focused with laser precision on massive deficit-financed tax cuts and limits on regulation that interfered with corporate profits. They were true laissez-faire free-marketeers, except when they could use the power of government to put a thumb on the scale in favor of the owners of capital. Their problem has been manifest for a long time - in order to gain the political power to achieve their ideological goals, a political organization needs voters. The Republicans had funding, they had leadership, they had a clear set of political goals - but the 1% makes a rather pathetic voting bloc. So the party leadership, in a very calculated manner, added a set of social issues over the core platform. It started with abortion, which led to an army of evangelical protestants, which led to southern whites, which led to disaffected working class bigots. So they adopted maximal positions on immigration, law & order, education, voting rights, affirmative action - anyplace they could drive a wedge into American society that would carve off another set of voters.

But along the way, this army of political ground troops, trained and honed by Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Fox News and the fever swamps of right wing media, began to notice that despite all the love and promises lavished upon them by the Republican Party, they kept losing. They were losing on immigration, on civil rights, on marriage equality, on environmental regulations. They were voting for a party that was damaging them economically in exchange for a return to 1950s social norms, and they kept getting nothing out of the deal. The Republicans thought of these people as 'their' voters, but what they didn't realize is that their loyalty to the Party was tenuous at best. What they wanted was a political organization that would use its power to advance their social issues, and they really didn't care if it cost the wealthy some income and businesses some profits.

The stood by in rising frustration as the party establishment replaced their tea party firebrands with first John McCain and then with Mitt Romney. They knew what they wanted, they just didn't know how to get it. And then along came Donald Trump. Northern, often somewhat liberal billionaire blowhard, he could clearly see who made up the Republican Party, and he spoke to them. He addressed their fear of the  other, their anger at the shifting norms of a modern, diverse culture. He used the same coarse language of racial and tribal insults they used - no longer coded 'dog whistles', but he just said back to them what they KNEW to be true. And now, as a result, the party has the leaders and the donors, but Donald Trump has the voters.

So now people are looking at this civil war between the traditional Republicans and the movement conservatives they courted for years, but never married, and they tell us the this will 'destroy' the party. And that's silly - the party has been a dysfunctional marriage of convenience for decades, and Trump is in the process of putting it back together again. No matter what happens in the 2016 election cycle, the GOP is never going to be the same. They are going to have to follow Trump's lead, defining a kind of conservative populism that actually attempts to deliver what the voting base wants, even if it costs them some of the Chamber of Commerce 1%. The Republican Party will exist - stronger than ever, as it moves at long last in the direction of its base voters. The message will have to evolve, and the emphasis will have to change. When they take power, they will still cut taxes and regulations, but they will also have to follow through on the red-meat promises them made to their voters.

This may not be a good thing for America - but it is an undeniable win for the American conservative voter.
...

6 comments:

  1. So question. After the (almost certain) Trump disaster in the general do you think the Republicans will remain a viable national political party and if not will a third party arise to fill the void?

    My opinion is they will manage to salvage something and no, America has never had a viable third party but I'm curious what you think.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To be clear I don't think the 'conservative base' is strong enough by itself to be viable.

      Delete
    2. And to be fair-ish, in a two-party system, no party is really viable based on one narrow part of the electorate. Republicans rely on the conservative base, and the evangelicals, and to corporate criminals, and the authoritarians, and the gun-fondlers, and the woman-controllers.... Democrats have the poor, minorities, women who want to control their own bodies, liberals, progressives, (some) hippies, people who like to fuck, stoners (although they usually miss the voting day).

      Delete
  2. Weird (can I call you Weird?) I am positive that the Republicans will remain a viable national party, from the standpoint of Congress, which is where much power resides anyway, at least the power they care about: the power to obstruct.

    Look at how the House is gerrymandered. almost every district is so safe, that it encourages them to be as crazy as they wanna be.

    As we know, the Presidency was designed to be a relatively weak, if high-profile, position; the fear of creating a monarch of sorts was kind of uppermost. Winning the White House does create a certain amount of momentum and such.

    As with the 2008, election, they will accept being out of power at the executive level, if they can continue to obstruct at every other level. They will wait until the Stupid American People forget, and elect another one of those authoritarian, semi-fascist motherfuckers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are welcome to call me Weird (I do).

      After re-reading mikey's post (reading comprehension, how do they work?), he pretty much answered my questions already, yes the Republicans will remain viable and no there won't be a third party.

      Delete
  3. Intent of the Founding Effers aside, we seem to have settled on/into a two-party system, so it isn't as if there'll only be Dems. I s'pect the Republicans, esp. in Congress, may hold together more or less as we know them a few more elections, but by 2024, say, things may be quite different.

    Hold me to that, I dare ya!

    ReplyDelete